Cognitive Science & Policy Hub // Vol. 12

Behavioral Economics Lab

The Nudge & Bias Lab — an interactive, citable directory of cognitive biases, peer-reviewed journals, and empirical nudge findings.

Social Influence

Trust, Beliefs and Cooperation: An Experiment

Duk Gyoo Kim, Louis Putterman, Xinyi Zhang

EconStor Working Paper · 2019

Abstract

Examines how beliefs about others' trustworthiness form and update, and how those beliefs sustain or unravel cooperation over repeated interactions.

Methodology

Controlled experiment eliciting subjects' beliefs alongside their trusting and cooperative choices, allowing the authors to separate the role of expectations from that of social preferences.

Findings

Cooperation is tightly linked to beliefs about others' behavior: accurate, optimistic beliefs support trust, while pessimistic belief-updating after negative experiences drives cooperation downward, showing that trust is as much a belief problem as a preference problem.

Applied nudge

Manage expectations, not just incentives—seed accurate optimistic beliefs about how cooperatively others behave, because a single salient betrayal can collapse trust faster than incentives can rebuild it.

Citation

Kim, D. G., Putterman, L., & Zhang, X. (2019). Trust, beliefs and cooperation: An experiment. EconStor Working Paper.

Download PDF